Editorial Standards and Corrections

This page sets out how the guides on internalauditguide.com are sourced, written, checked and corrected, so that a reader can judge how far to rely on them. Who is behind the site is on the About page; how to reach the desk is on the Contact page.

Sources

Guides work from the primary text: the standard, the rule, the regulator’s own guidance or the framework itself, named with its paragraph or section number. Where a point is common practice and no rule requires it, the guide says so. A rule that binds the external auditor is not presented as a rule that binds management, and a staff position is not presented as a rule.

Facts that move carry a date: thresholds, fees, deadlines, proposals that are not yet final. Guides published or reviewed since November 2026 link their sources; earlier guides cite the source by name and paragraph.

How a guide is checked

Before a guide goes live, a separate review pass reads its factual claims against the sources they come from: numbers, dates, paragraph references, thresholds and the arithmetic in every example. Guides already published are re-read the same way when a rule changes and in sweeps of a whole subject. When a sweep finds an error, the guide is corrected and the change is recorded in the log at the foot of this page.

How AI is used

Three things build this library together. Practicing auditors decide what is worth writing and what each guide has to get right. Their experience sets the rules a guide is held to: which sources count, what has to be dated, what an example has to show. Advanced AI models do the research, drafting and cross-checking at a scale a small desk could not reach alone. None of the three is enough without the other two.

What goes live is decided by the check and not by the tool: a claim stays in a guide because it matches the primary source, whoever or whatever drafted the sentence.

Worked examples use invented organizations

The organizations in the worked examples are invented. Lakeshore Bancorp, MidState Beverage, Halberd Software, Thornwick Bank, Pennine Foods, Caldera Mutual, Tamarack Stores and the other example companies were made up for these guides. Their figures are built to be realistic and to stay consistent from guide to guide; they are not taken from any real company, and a resemblance to a real organization, including one with a similar name, is coincidental.

Real organizations and real cases, such as enforcement actions and public control failures, are named as such and tied to a public source.

Independence

The site takes no vendor money, runs no affiliate links and accepts no sponsored placements. Software reviews are research from public sources and say so; no vendor sees or approves a review before it is published. The books and PDFs offered on the site are its own.

The guides are educational and general. They are not audit, legal or financial advice for a particular organization.

Reporting an error

Write to desk@internalauditguide.com with the page and the sentence. Corrections are answered first. A change of fact is made in the guide and recorded below; typos and wording are fixed without a log entry.

Corrections log

Review of the SOX and ITGC guides, 10 November 2026

DateGuideWhat changed
10 Nov 2026SOX 404 ExplainedThe FDICIA Part 363 threshold for the management assessment of internal control and the auditor’s attestation corrected to five billion dollars, in force since 1 January 2026 (the guide said one billion). Filer-status conditions and exits completed from Exchange Act Rule 12b-2.
10 Nov 2026SOX for Control OwnersThe opening said the CEO and CFO certify every quarter that internal control over financial reporting is effective. Corrected to what the quarterly certification covers; effectiveness is assessed once a year.
10 Nov 2026SOX 302 vs 404 vs 906The accelerated filer test, the ways a company leaves a filer category, the emerging growth company period and the foreign private issuer answer corrected to Rule 12b-2, Regulation S-K Item 308 and Form 20-F.
10 Nov 2026SOX Scoping and Risk AssessmentArithmetic in the worked example corrected (32 controls removed, not 29). The exclusion of an acquired business restated as the SEC staff’s non-objection position, with its limits.
10 Nov 2026Evaluating Control DeficienciesThe illustration of compensating-control precision corrected. The bar on concluding that control is effective with a material weakness attributed to Item 308(a)(3), which is a rule and not guidance.
10 Nov 2026IT General Controls: The Complete PrimerThe external auditor’s use of internal audit’s work attributed to PCAOB AS 2605 and AS 2201, not to IIA Standard 9.5. The service organization example corrected so that a six-month gap is not bridged by a letter alone.
10 Nov 2026Test of Design vs Operating EffectivenessParagraph references to PCAOB AS 2201 corrected.
10 Nov 2026How to Review a SOC 1 Report and three related guidesA bridge letter described as a representation by the service organization’s management, not assurance; the three-month convention stated the same way in each guide.
10 Nov 2026Pre-IPO SOX Readiness and Internal Audit After an IPOThe emerging growth company period, the due date of a new registrant’s first Form 10-Q and the filing date of the NYSE internal audit proposal corrected.
10 Nov 2026IPE TestingThe amendments to PCAOB AS 1105 made by Release No. 2024-007 added.

Guide-by-guide review of the most-read guides, begun 10 November 2026

DateGuideWhat changed
10 Nov 2026The CIA Exam SyllabusThe table of what moved in Part 1 placed the function’s independence under Ethics and Professionalism. Corrected to the IIA’s syllabus, which lists it under Foundations.
10 Nov 2026CIA Exam DatesRetake and Challenge Exam fees were given without a year. Dated as 2026 fees, and the fees that apply from 4 January 2027 added from the IIA’s 2027 price list.
10 Nov 2026Optro ReviewProduct count updated from ten to eleven after the vendor’s October 2026 launch. The conference where the rename was announced corrected to the IIA’s Great Audit Minds conference. The Capterra listing and the Workiva price median brought up to what those sources show in November 2026.
10 Nov 2026SOX Compliance Software ComparedPrice medians attributed to Vendr’s buyer data, not to the vendors, and the Workiva median updated to the figure Vendr shows in November 2026.
10 Nov 2026The ACFE Fraud Tree ExplainedBilling schemes were called the most common asset-misappropriation scheme in every recent Report to the Nations; corrected to one of the two most common. Capability attributed to the fraud diamond, not the fraud triangle.
10 Nov 2026Audit Sample Sizes: 25, 40, 60A sentence said a 5% tolerable rate needs roughly triple the sample of 10%; the guide’s own grid shows roughly double. The description of the small-population method corrected to match how its tables are computed.
10 Nov 2026AI Prompts for Internal AuditorsStandard 14.1 was said to require information that is sufficient, reliable, relevant and useful. The Standard names three qualities, and the fourth was removed in two places.
11 Nov 2026Types of Internal Audit SoftwareA Gartner benchmark described as a September 2026 survey restated as published in September 2026. Optro’s lead in review volume limited to Gartner Peer Insights. The board’s role in audit independence attributed to Principle 7 of the Standards, not Principle 8.
10 Nov 2026CRMA CertificationA table said CRMA maintenance is free alongside the CIA. Corrected: the IIA charges a CRMA renewal fee, and only the CPE is shared. Fees dated as 2026 prices, and the pause in new enrollments on the IRM’s International Diploma noted.
10 Nov 2026COSO’s 17 PrinciplesPrinciple 16 corrected to COSO’s wording, ongoing and/or separate evaluations. Standard 13.4 restated: evaluation criteria are required for assurance engagements. The worked example’s count of observations corrected from four to five.
10 Nov 2026Audit Workpaper ExampleTwo abridged rows in the results table gave the wrong number of items (19 and 3). Corrected to 14 and 8; the totals were already right.

Guide-by-guide review, continued 11 November 2026

DateGuideWhat changed
11 Nov 2026CIA Exam Passing ScoreThe comparison table said CFA Institute does not publish its minimum passing score. Corrected to the scores its results guide gives for each level.
11 Nov 2026Maintaining the CIAThe Part 1 fee for recertification was given without a year. Dated as the 2026 fee, with the fee from 4 January 2027 added.
11 Nov 2026The CIA Challenge ExamThe syllabus table listed due professional care under Section A; the IIA’s syllabus lists confidentiality. Quality material attributed to Part 3 of the three-part syllabus, not Part 1. Fees dated as 2026 prices with the 2027 list added, and the status of the experience pilot updated.
11 Nov 2026Optro vs WorkivaWorkiva’s name change corrected from 2012 to 2014. Workiva’s public-sector contract vehicles added (the guide said none were found). Vendr price figures, Workiva’s cash position and the status of its automated testing agents updated to November 2026, and the cost illustration recomputed.
11 Nov 2026SOX Compliance Software ComparedDiligent’s separately named SOX product, Internal Controls, added (the guide said none was found). Hyperproof added as a product with public price evidence. Vendr medians for Workiva, Diligent and ServiceNow updated to November 2026.
11 Nov 2026Internal Audit Software PricingIdeagen’s legacy edition price corrected: the listed £13,870 is ten named-user licenses, not an instance fee with users on top. Vendr figures updated to November 2026 and the five-year worksheet recomputed.
11 Nov 2026OCC Risk CategoriesRisk data aggregation guidance was attributed to OCC Bulletin 2013-29, which was third-party guidance and has been rescinded; corrected to the heightened standards guidelines (12 CFR part 30, appendix D). The definitions table brought to the current Comptroller’s Handbook wording, and reputation risk marked as no longer an OCC category since 2025. Statements that the OCC has nine categories corrected: its count is seven, and the nine are this guide’s own headings.
11 Nov 2026The COSO Framework GuidePrinciple 16 corrected to COSO’s wording, ongoing and/or separate evaluations. COSO’s 2006 guidance for smaller public companies described as superseded by the 2013 framework, not updated. The requirement to use a suitable, recognized framework attributed to the SEC’s rules, not to section 404 itself.
11 Nov 2026Risk and Control Matrix TemplateA requirement to describe controls was attributed to Standard 13.2; restated as what the Standard requires. Principle 16 corrected to COSO’s wording. A word count in an example corrected from five to four.
11 Nov 2026Data Analytics Tools for Internal AuditorsVendor facts corrected at the vendors’ own pages: Arbutus’s head office, the Alteryx sale price and its source, MindBridge’s investors, and KNIME’s published team price. Two survey figures moved from the IIA’s 2025 Pulse report to the Vision 2035 survey they come from. Counts in the comparison corrected (seven of eight tools rated a strong fit; six of eight have their own review).
11 Nov 2026Monetary Unit SamplingThe evidence test was quoted as sufficient, reliable, relevant and useful and tied to Standard 14.2. Corrected to the three qualities in Standard 14.1. Three statements that the site’s mySampler tool evaluates monetary unit samples corrected: it performs the selection.
11 Nov 2026Archer AlternativesMetricStream’s security certifications added (the guide said none were published) and its investor’s board seats updated. IBM OpenPages pricing on AWS corrected: the low figure is a base plan, and the audit application is priced separately. Vendr medians, Optro’s product count and Diligent’s AI model updated to November 2026. A description of the Protecht chief executive’s background corrected.
11 Nov 2026Archer vs ServiceNow IRMServiceNow’s Vendr median updated to November 2026 and the five-year cost table recomputed. Two figures from Archer described as model counts, not training-data claims. The number of ServiceNow IRM applications no longer stated as six.
11 Nov 2026The Global Internal Audit StandardsA self-check question said the internal audit strategy is approved by the board; Standard 9.2 has it reviewed with the board and senior management. The status of the upcoming Topical Requirements dated to November 2026.
11 Nov 2026How to Create an Internal Audit CharterThe twelve-month cooling period for auditors who move from operations was called common practice; it comes from the requirements of Standard 2.2. A reference to standards beyond Domain III corrected: the standards listed are in Domain III.
11 Nov 2026Sawyer’s Guide for Internal AuditorsA comparison row said Standard 14.6 makes access to engagement documentation explicit; it covers retention and supervision.
11 Nov 2026The Audit SocietyThe paperback was described as identical in text to the hardback; it adds a preface to the paperback edition.
11 Nov 2026AI Tools for Internal AuditMindBridge’s September 2026 features described as announced, with one agent in preview, not all launched. The count of products covered corrected from sixteen to seventeen. Archer’s accuracy claims described as the result of its own published test. Diligent’s AI model and Blast Audit’s features updated to November 2026.
11 Nov 2026Evaluating AI in Audit SoftwareOnspring was said to state a no-training position; its pages carry no such statement. ServiceNow’s documented use of customer inputs to improve its models, with an opt-out, added (the guide said no statement was found). Model providers named for Workiva, IBM OpenPages and MetricStream. IBM’s extra charge for AI components and DataSnipper’s retention period added. Diligent’s and LogicGate’s models updated to November 2026.
11 Nov 2026TeamMate ReviewThe comparison table said Ideagen has no public price; its UK government listing price added. Workiva’s Vendr median updated to November 2026. Diligent’s orchestration agent dated to its September 2026 announcement, not March 2026.
11 Nov 2026Diligent One Platform ReviewThe Reports app was said to reach end of life on 30 September 2026; Diligent has deferred that with no new date. AI Reporting described as generally available since 15 September 2026, not an early adopter program. ACL AI Studio’s model and regions, the Robots Agent security requirement and the import of older file formats corrected to Diligent’s current documentation. Vendr figures updated to November 2026. Standard 14.6 wording corrected, and the Steele acquisition described as agreed in February 2021.
11 Nov 2026Engagement-Level Risk AssessmentA count in the text corrected from six to eight, to match the eight statements in the guide’s own table.
11 Nov 2026Workpaper Best PracticesThe qualities of evidence under Standard 14.1 were given in the wording of the 2017 Standards; restated from the 2024 definitions. Access to and release of engagement records attributed to Standard 5.2, not 14.6. AuditBoard named under its current name, Optro.
11 Nov 2026Entity-Level ControlsThe guide said only precise entity-level controls can reduce the testing of process-level controls. Corrected to PCAOB AS 2201 paragraph .23: precise controls can replace that testing, and effective monitoring controls may reduce it.
11 Nov 2026Internal Audit Plan TemplateAn answer said Standard 9.4 requires the plan to consider the work of other assurance providers. That requirement is in Standard 9.5; the answer now gives the coverage Standard 9.4 itself names.
11 Nov 2026The Audit Work ProgramThe title of Standard 13.6 corrected to Work Program.
11 Nov 2026CIA Exam Questions and AnswersThree answer explanations corrected to the Standards’ requirements. Question 20: Standard 13.2 requires considering the significance of risks and the potential for fraud. Question 40: the results of prior engagements removed from what Standard 9.4 requires. Question 5: a source reference corrected.
11 Nov 2026CIA Exam Part 1The group of Internal Audit Practitioner holders with the 31 May 2026 deadline corrected to those awarded on or before 27 May 2025.

Guide-by-guide review, continued 11 November 2026 (second part)

DateGuideWhat changed
11 Nov 2026Types of Internal Audit SoftwareOnspring removed from the vendors said to publish a no-training policy for their AI features; Resolver publishes one, Onspring does not.
11 Nov 2026Best Internal Audit Software in 2026Optro’s lead in review volume limited to Gartner Peer Insights (Workiva has more reviews on G2). Optro’s module count, Archer’s customer count, the Vendr figures and Diligent’s AI model updated to November 2026. Ideagen’s legacy price itemized as ten named-user licenses, and IBM OpenPages pricing on AWS corrected to a base plan plus a separately priced application. Caseware IDEA’s Python support no longer dated to version 13. Arbutus’s location corrected to Vancouver.
11 Nov 2026Optro vs ArcherVendr’s $100,000 figure for Archer was called a legal-review threshold; it is Vendr’s redline threshold, the spend at which a supplier accepts legal edits. Archer described as having spent years inside RSA Security, not as having begun there. Optro’s module count updated to November 2026, and a count of Archer’s automated data feeds removed.
11 Nov 2026Optro vs ServiceNow IRMServiceNow’s documented use of customer inputs to improve its AI models, with an opt-out, added (the guide said no statement was found). ServiceNow’s deployment corrected from SaaS only: a minority of customers run it in their own or third-party data centers. Optro’s ownership by Hg dated to the agreement announced 23 May 2024. ServiceNow’s Vendr figures updated to November 2026.
11 Nov 2026IDEA vs Arbutus vs ACLThe guide said Arbutus’s own site makes no one-click claim for converting ACL projects; it advertises 1-Click project conversion, with no compatibility percentage. Arbutus’s head office corrected to Vancouver. The version in which ACL gained its Python command corrected from 19 to 18, and a statement that all three tools added Python within about a year of each other removed. A quotation from a Diligent release replaced with a summary. Diligent’s AI model, the Reports app retirement and the Vendr figures updated to November 2026.
11 Nov 2026Workiva Review for Internal Audit and SOXWorkiva’s name change corrected from 2012 to July 2014. A quoted duration for an implementation phase removed: the statement of work gives none. Optro, named as charging for extra users, corrected: it advertises unlimited stakeholder licenses. Optro’s lead in review count limited to Gartner Peer Insights; Workiva has more reviews on G2. Vendr figures, customer counts, cash and the status of the automated testing agents updated to November 2026.
11 Nov 2026MetricStream vs ArcherMetricStream’s ISO 27001 certification and SOC 2 Type II attestation added (the guide said none were found), and published certifications removed from the reasons to prefer Archer. MetricStream’s statements on AI models and data use added. MetricStream’s five-year cost total recomputed and its price range corrected to the source’s figures. The scorecard summary corrected to match the scorecard. A count of Archer’s data feeds removed, Archer’s benchmark described as its own published test, and three quotations that could not be found word for word turned into summaries. Vendr’s $100,000 figure for Archer described as its redline threshold.
11 Nov 2026Caseware IDEA ReviewCaseware’s Verity releases described as framed around assurance engagements; they do not name Working Papers. IDEA’s version names, the test count of its Financial App and the source of its integrations list corrected to Caseware’s brochure and documentation. The statement that Caseware publishes nothing on data use corrected: its AiDA release says prompts are not stored or fed back into the model. A quotation about AiDA replaced with the brochure’s wording. The split of G2 reviewers corrected: the mid-market and small-business shares were transposed.
11 Nov 2026Audit Software for Small Internal Audit TeamsThe City of Norman record dated correctly: the vendor’s quote is dated 28 February 2025 and the council agenda 13 May 2025. Workiva’s lowest Vendr figure updated to November 2026.
11 Nov 2026IBM OpenPages vs ServiceNow IRMIBM OpenPages pricing on AWS corrected: the low figure is a required base plan and an application is priced on top, so the five-year cost table was recomputed (total $242,640, was $177,540). ServiceNow’s documented use of customer inputs to improve its AI models, with an opt-out, added (the guide said neither vendor publishes a data-use statement), and its deployment corrected from SaaS only. The MCP server in OpenPages 9.2 described as open-sourced, not managed. Cognos Analytics no longer described as bundled into every tier. An ISO/IEC 27001 statement for OpenPages added from IBM’s UK government listing. Named audit customers limited to Citi. Vendr figures updated to November 2026.
11 Nov 2026Walkthrough Documentation TemplateThe contents list named four walkthrough failures; the section lists five.
11 Nov 2026Best CIA Review Courses in 2026Becker’s installment-plan fee for CIA courses corrected from up to $119 to up to $89. A chapter discount on Gleim corrected from half off to 30 percent. Becker’s single-part access described as the longest fixed term, since Gleim’s runs until you pass. The end date of Becker’s current promotion updated.
11 Nov 2026Failed the CIA Exam: Retake PlanThe guide said nothing appears on screen when the exam ends; it is the score that does not appear. Retake fees dated as 2026 prices, with the fees from 4 January 2027 added.
11 Nov 2026MindBridge ReviewMindBridge’s investors added (the guide said none were stated): PSG Equity invested $60 million in April 2023, alongside PeakSpan and Real Ventures. Its September 2026 AI features described as announced, with one agent in preview, not launched. The body that certified its 2021 algorithm audit named. The guide said no customer choice of data location is described; the data processing addendum lets a subscriber set it in an order form. An executive’s title, the scope of a partner deployment and smaller figures corrected at MindBridge’s own pages.
11 Nov 2026DataSnipper ReviewUpLink described as an add-on module, not a feature of the top tier. The chief executive’s appointment on 1 June 2023 and background added (the guide said they were not stated), and the Series B announcement dated 1 February 2024. A customer result no longer tied to a specific AI agent. The 24-hour deletion of AI-processed documents limited to the one feature DataSnipper states it for. An anecdotal price that could not be traced removed. Counts and prices updated to November 2026.
11 Nov 2026The QAIP PlaybookThe rating scale external assessors use was given as three levels; under the IIA’s 2024 Quality Assessment Manual it has four, with fully conforms added. The evidence qualities at the fieldwork checkpoint corrected to the three in Standard 14.1. A reference to the CIA Part 3 syllabus corrected from Domain C to Section C.
11 Nov 2026QAIP Self-Assessment TemplateThe workbook’s rating list brought to the four-level scale of the IIA’s 2024 Quality Assessment Manual, with a definition of fully conforms added. A checklist item’s evidence qualities corrected to the three in Standard 14.1.
11 Nov 2026Internal Audit Books: A Reading ListEditions brought up to date at the publishers’ own pages: Internal Auditing: Assurance and Advisory Services (6th edition), Fraud Examination (7th edition), Style: Lessons in Clarity and Grace (13th edition) and The Phoenix Project. The Three Lines Model dated with the IIA’s July 2026 Statement of Position. The IIA’s continuing education rule for self-study corrected: it asks for evidence of completion, not an assessment.
11 Nov 2026Internal Audit Jargon ExplainedConformance ratings given on the four-level scale external assessors now use. Model validation described as set out in supervisory guidance that is not binding, not as required.
11 Nov 2026Internal Audit Software PricingA second pass the same day: the City of Norman record described as a quote dated 28 February 2025 that went to the council on 13 May 2025, not a council agenda of 28 February. Vendr’s $100,000 figure for Archer described as its redline threshold, the spend at which a supplier accepts legal edits. IBM OpenPages pricing on AWS corrected to a required base plan plus a separately priced application, and MetricStream’s price estimates corrected to the source’s upper figure of $1,000,000.
11 Nov 2026Best Internal Audit Software in 2026A second pass the same day: the City of Norman record described as a quote dated 28 February 2025 that went to the council on 13 May 2025, not a council agenda of 28 February.
11 Nov 2026Archer vs ServiceNow IRMA second pass the same day: Vendr’s $100,000 figure for Archer described as its redline threshold, the spend at which a supplier accepts legal edits, not a trigger for legal review. A count of Archer’s data feeds removed. ServiceNow’s deployment corrected from SaaS only: a minority of customers run it in their own or third-party data centers.
11 Nov 2026Archer AlternativesA second pass the same day: Vendr’s $100,000 figure for Archer described as its redline threshold, not a trigger for legal review.
11 Nov 2026The Global Internal Audit StandardsA second pass the same day: assessor ratings given on the four-level scale of the IIA’s 2024 Quality Assessment Manual, not three. Two rows of the crosswalk from the 2017 Standards corrected against the IIA’s own mapping: seven of the ten Core Principles map to principles in Domains II to IV, and the 2200 series maps to Standards 13.2 to 13.6.